What is the difference between legal and lawful?

| Posted on |

The terms “legal” and “lawful” are often used interchangeably, but they have distinct meanings and connotations that can be important in certain contexts.

Legal

  • Definition: “Legal” refers to something that is in accordance with the laws that are formally enacted and recognized by a governing authority, such as statutes, regulations, or case law.
  • Scope: It is concerned with the technical and procedural aspects of the law. If something is legal, it means it adheres to the rules, procedures, and codes set out in written laws.
  • Context: “Legal” often relates to the letter of the law. For example, a contract is legal if it meets the requirements set out by the relevant statutes and regulations, regardless of whether the terms of the contract are ethical or fair.

Lawful

  • Definition: “Lawful” refers to something that is not only in compliance with statutory law but also aligns with broader principles of justice, morality, and ethical standards. It is in harmony with both the written law and the principles of natural law or common law.
  • Scope: “Lawful” encompasses not just what is written in statutes but also what is right and just in a broader sense. It can imply adherence to the spirit of the law or principles of fairness and justice.
  • Context: “Lawful” often relates to the spirit of the law and moral considerations. For example, an action might be “legal” under statutory law but could be considered “unlawful” if it violates basic human rights or natural justice.

Examples

  • Legal but Unlawful: A situation can be “legal” but not “lawful.” For example, a law may technically allow a company to pollute within certain limits, making the pollution “legal,” but if that pollution causes significant harm to the environment and people, it might be considered “unlawful” in a moral or natural law sense.
  • Lawful but Not Legal: Conversely, an action could be “lawful” in the sense of being morally right or just, even if it is not “legal” under current statutory law. For example, civil disobedience or breaking an unjust law might be seen as “lawful” from a moral standpoint, even if it is not “legal.”

Conclusion

  • Legal focuses on adherence to the written, codified laws and rules.
  • Lawful encompasses a broader sense of justice, ethics, and morality, beyond just what is written in statutes.

Understanding the difference between these terms can be crucial, especially in discussions about the justice system, ethics, and governance.